Predominant low Hematopoietic Cell Transplantation Specific Comorbidity Index (HCT-CI) score in a Mexican referral center: a selection bias caused by limited-resources?

Abstract Introduction: To date, many studies have validated the Hematopoietic Cell Transplantation Specific Comorbidity Index (HCT-CI) scoring system in allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (allo-HSCT), but studies from developing countries remain scarce. Objective: The aim of this study was to evaluate and categorize Mexican patients using the HCT-CI at a referral center. Methods: One hundred and nineteen consecutive patients undergoing allo-HSCT at the National Institute of Medical Sciences and Nutrition in Mexico City were included. Patients were classified according to the HCT-CI scores. Results: The median age was 31 years and most were males (56%). Most patients had hematological malignancies (73%) and a low HCT-CI score (72%). The non-relapse mortality and survival were predicted according to the score. Conclusions: This is one of the few studies to evaluate the HCT-CI in adults with HLA-matched donors in a developing country and our findings suggest that the high percentage of patients with a low HCT-CI scores, contrary to international reports, could be explained by different comorbidities and demographics, but mainly due to stricter filters applied to HSCT candidates and consequently, a potential selection bias caused by limited resources.

Comparison of matched sibling, unrelated and haploidentical donors in hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. A real world experience from the Argentine Group For Bone Marrow Transplantation And Cell Therapy (GATMO-TC) / Comparación de donantes relacionados, no relacionados y haploidénticos en trasplante de progenitores hematopoyéticos. Experiencia del Grupo Argentino de Trasplante de Médula Ósea y Terapia Celular (GATMO-TC)

Abstract We retrospectively analyzed 570 adult patients who received allogeneic stem cell transplantation for malignant diseases. The outcomes were compared according to donor type. Most of the patients (60%) were transplanted for acute leukemia. Median follow-up was 1.6 years. Haploidentical allogeneic stem cell transplantation was more frequently performed for acute myeloid leukemia and in late stages than any other donor type. Non-relapse mortality at 100 days and one year for unrelated and haploidentical donors were similar, 19%-29% vs. 17%-28%, respectively. A significant better non-relapse mortality was observed for matched sibling donors (7%-15%; p < 0.001). Relapse rate was higher in haploidentical donors compared to matched sibling and unrelated donors (three year relapse rate 46%, 39%, 28%; respectively p < 0.001). Haploidentical donors resulted in lower three year progression-free survival and worse 3 year overall survival (32%; p < 0.001 and 42%; p < 0.001) compared with other donors (44% and 55% MSD, 40% and 42% UD, respectively). The incidence of grade II-IV acute graft-versus-host disease was higher in unrelated donors (51% unrelated, 35% haploidentical, 36% matched sibling; respectively; p = 0.001), with no difference in grades III-IV (p = 0.73) or in chronic graft-versus-host disease (p = 0.2) between groups. After multivariate analysis, haploidentical and unrelated donors remained negatively associated with non-relapse mortality (HR 1.95; 95% CI 1.10-3.20 and HR 2.70; 95% CI 1.63-4.46, respectively). Haploidentical donors were associated with a higher risk of relapse and worse overall survival. This analysis shows that haploidentical donors were associated with similar non-relpase mortality and higher relapse rates than unrelated donors. Better results in non-relapse mortality were observed for matched sibling donors.

Resumen Se efectuó un análisis retrospectivo de 570 pacientes adultos que recibieron un trasplante alogénico de precursores hematopoyéticos, comparando los resultados según el tipo de donante. La mediana de seguimiento fue de 1.6 años. El 60% de la población se trasplantó por leucemias agudas. Los trasplantes haploidénticos se hicieron en su mayoría en leucemia mieloide aguda y en estadios tardíos en comparación a otros donantes. La mortalidad libre de enfermedad al día +100 y a 1 año fue similar para los donantes no emparentados y haploidénticos (19% y 29% vs. 17% y 28%, respectivamente). Se obtuvieron mejores resultados con donantes relacionados idénticos (7% y 15%; p < 0.001). La recaída fue mayor en los donantes haploidénticos (tres años 46% haploidénticos, 39% relacionados idénticos, 28% no emparentados; p < 0.003). El trasplante con donante haploidéntico presentó una menor supervivencia libre de progresión y menor supervivencia global a tres años (32%; p < 0.001 y 42%; p < 0.001). La incidencia de enfermedad injerto contra huésped aguda fue mayor en no emparentados (51%, 35% haploidénticos, 36% relacionados idénticos; p = 0.001), sin diferencias en grados III-IV (p = 0.73) o en EICH crónica (p = 0.2). Los trasplantes con donante haploidéntico y no emparentado mantuvieron su asociación negativa con mortalidad libre de enfermedad (HR 1.95; 95%IC 1.10-3.20 y HR 2.70; 95%IC 1.63-4.46), en análisis multivariado. El trasplante haploidéntico se asoció a mayor recaída y a menor supervivencia global. Esta experiencia mostró similar mortalidad libre de enfermedad entre trasplantes con donantes haploidénticos y no emparentados. Los trasplantes relacionados idénticos mostraron menores tasas de mortalidad libre de enfermedad.

Validación del índice de comorbilidad para trasplante hematopoyético en una cohorte retrospectiva de niños y adolescentes argentinos receptores de trasplante alogénico / Validation of the Hematopoietic Cell Transplantation-Specific Comorbidity Index in a retrospective cohort of children and adolescents who received an allogeneic transplantation in Argentina

Introducción. El trasplante hematopoyético es una terapia con riesgo de mortalidad relacionada con el trasplante (MRT), que puede variar según la comorbilidad previa. El índice de comorbilidad para trasplante hematopoyético (ICTH) es un instrumento desarrollado para medir este riesgo. Los reportes sobre su uso en pediatría son escasos. El objetivo de este estudio fue validar el ICTH en una cohorte pediátrica de receptores de trasplante hematopoyético alogénico en Argentina. Población y métodos. Cohorte retrospectiva de 140 pacientes trasplantados en el Hospital J. P. Garrahan entre 2008 y 2012. Se revisaron, de las historias clínicas, sus antecedentes y evolución. Se calculó el ICTH de cada paciente y se clasificaron como de riesgo bajo (puntaje 0), intermedio (puntaje 1-2) o alto (puntaje > 3). Se estimó la supervivencia para cada grupo por el método de Kaplan-Meier y se comparó con la prueba de logaritmos de rangos. En el caso de las enfermedades malignas, la recaída fue considerada un evento competitivo con la MRT. Se consideró significativa una p < 0,05. Resultados. La mediana del ICTH fue 1 (r: 0-6). El 45,7% de los pacientes tuvieron puntaje 0; el 40,7%, 1-2; y el 13,6%, > 3. Las comorbilidades más frecuentes fueron obesidad, infección y compromiso pulmonar y hepático. La MRT de los pacientes con puntaje 0 fue 14,1%; con puntaje 1-2, 43,7%; y con puntaje > 3, 52,6%. Las curvas de supervivencia manifestaron diferencias entre los tres grupos (p 0,01). Conclusión. El ICTH mostró ser una herramienta efectiva para predecir el riesgo de MRT en nuestro medio.

Introduction. Hematopoietic cell transplantationis a therapy with a risk of transplant-related mortality (TRM), which may vary depending on prior comorbidities. The Hematopoietic Cell Transplantation-Specific Comorbidity Index (HCT-CI) is an instrument developed to measure this risk. There are very few reports on its use in pediatrics. The objective of this study was to validate the HCT-CI in a pediatric cohort of allogeneic hematopoietic-cell transplantation recipients in Argentina. Population and methods. Retrospective cohort made up of 140 transplant patients at Hospital J. P. Garrahan between 2008 and 2012. Medical records were reviewed to identify patient history and course. The HCT-CI was estimated for each patient, who was classified as having a low (score: 0), intermediate (score: 1-2) or high (score: >3) risk. Survival was estimated for each group using the Kaplan-Meier method and compared with the log-rank test. For malignancies, relapse was considered an event consistent with TRM. A p value <0.05 was considered significant. Results. The median score in the HCT-CI was 1 (r: 0-6). A score of 0 was observed in 45.7% of patients, 1-2 in 40.7%, and >3 in 13.6%. The most common comorbidities included obesity, infection, pulmonary and liver involvement. TRM was 14.1% among patients with a score of 0; 43.7% with a score of 1-2, and 52.6% with a score >3. Differences were observed among the survival curves of the three groups (p = 0.01). Conclusion. The HCT-CI demonstrated to be an effective tool to predict the risk of TRM in our setting.