Factors affecting treatment practices of patent medicine vendors for malaria in under-five children: implications for malaria control in Nigeria

Background: Patent medicine vendors (PMVs) are the most common source of antimalarial drugs and treatment for majority of Nigerians. The quality of their practice could have implications for malaria control. This study sought to explore the factors influencing the malaria treatment practices of PMVs for under-five children in Akwa Ibom State. Methods: A cross-sectional survey using an interviewer-administered questionnaire was conducted among 176 PMVs selected by simple random sampling from two local government areas (LGAs). In addition, four focus group discussions (FGD) were conducted to generate qualitative data. Quantitative data was analysed using SPSS version 20 while content analysis was done on the qualitative data. Results: Artemisinin Combination Therapy (ACT) was the most frequently recommended antimalarial treatment by PMVs (75.6%) for children as against chloroquine (17%) and Sulphadoxine/Pyrimethamine (2.8%). However, only 39.2% of PMVs recommended the appropriate antimalarial treatment (ACTs at the right dose for age), while 71% recommended referral for severe malaria. Factors found to be associated with appropriate management of malaria from quantitative analysis included Educational qualification, attending malaria training and their knowledge of malaria. The FGDs showed that severity of child's illness, parents/caregivers drug request and perceived ability of the parents/caregiver to afford the drugs influenced PMVs malaria treatment practices. Conclusion: Knowledge of malaria, severity of child's illness and parents' drug request influenced the treatment practices of PMVs. Training PMVs on appropriate malaria management and community health education/sensitization to leverage on the influence of client-demand on ACT use is recommended to improve PMVs treatment practice

Glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency and the use of primaquine: top-down and bottom-up estimation of professional costs / Deficiência de glicose-6-fosfato desidrogenase e uso de primaquina: estimativa de custos de profissionais por macrocusteio e microcusteio

ABSTRACT The aim of this study has been to study whether the top-down method, based on the average value identified in the Brazilian Hospitalization System (SIH/SUS), is a good estimator of the cost of health professionals per patient, using the bottom-up method for comparison. The study has been developed from the context of hospital care offered to the patient carrier of glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) deficiency with severe adverse effect because of the use of primaquine, in the Brazilian Amazon. The top-down method based on the spending with SIH/SUS professional services, as a proxy for this cost, corresponded to R$60.71, and the bottom-up, based on the salaries of the physician (R$30.43), nurse (R$16.33), and nursing technician (R$5.93), estimated a total cost of R$52.68. The difference was only R$8.03, which shows that the amounts paid by the Hospital Inpatient Authorization (AIH) are estimates close to those obtained by the bottom-up technique for the professionals directly involved in the care.

RESUMO A pesquisa teve por objetivo estudar se o macrocusteio, baseado no valor médio identificado no Sistema de Internação Hospitalar (SIH/SUS), constitui um bom estimador do custo de profissionais de saúde por paciente, tendo como comparação o método de microcusteio. O estudo foi desenvolvido no contexto da assistência hospitalar oferecida ao portador da deficiência de glicose-6-fosfato desidrogenase (dG6PD) do sexo masculino com evento adverso grave devido ao uso da primaquina, na Amazônia Brasileira. O macrocusteio baseado no gasto em serviços profissionais do SIH/SUS, como proxy desse custo, correspondeu a R$60,71, e o microcusteio, baseado nos salários do médico (R$30,43), do enfermeiro (R$16,33) e do técnico de enfermagem (R$5,93), estimou um custo total de R$52,68. A diferença foi de apenas R$8,03, mostrando que os valores pagos pela Autorização de Internação Hospitalar (AIH) são estimadores próximos daqueles obtidos por técnica de microcusteio para os profissionais envolvidos diretamente no cuidado.

Análisis de costo efectividad de la vitamina A en niños menores de 5 años en Colombia / Cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA) regarding vitamin A in children aged less than 5 years-old in Colombia

Objetivo evaluar la costo-efectividad relativa del uso de vitamina a en los niños menores de 5 años en la disminución de eventos de diarrea, malaria y la mortalidad, bajo la perspectiva del sistema de salud colombiano (SGSSS). Materiales y Métodos se construyó unárbol de decisión con muertes evitadas como desenlace. Las probabilidades se extrajeron de la literatura y los costos de fuentes oficiales. El umbral de costo-efectividad fue tres veces el producto interno bruto (PIB) per cápita colombiano de 2012. Se realizaron análisis de sensibilidad determinísticos, probabilísticos y curva de aceptabilidad. Resultados En una cohorte de cien mil niños, la administración de vitamina a, frente no hacerlo, representaría un ahorro en costos de atención médica de $ 340.306.917, debido a que reduce el número de eventos de diarrea (4.268) y de malaria (76), así como los casos en los que se requiere hospitalización. En todos los análisis de sensibilidad se obtuvo un ahorro para el sistema. Conclusión Dentro del sistema de salud colombiano, la suplementación con vitamina a para niños menores de 5 años, comparado con no hacerlo, es la estrategia menos costosa y más efectiva (dominante).

Objective Evaluating the relative cost-effectiveness of using vitamin A in children aged less than 5-years-old regarding the reduction of events involving diarrhoea, malaria and mortality from the Colombian health-related social security system (CHSSS). Materials and Methods A decision tree was constructed, using deaths averted as outcome. Probabilities were taken from the pertinent literature and costs from official sources. The cost-effectiveness threshold was three times greater than the per capita Colombian gross domestic product (GDP) in 2012. Probabilistic and deterministic sensitivity analyses were made and cost effectiveness acceptability curves were drawn. Results Providing a cohort of 100,000 children with vitamin A (as opposed to not doing so) would represent a saving regarding medical attention costs of $ 340,306,917 due to the number of events involving diarrhea (4,268) and malaria (76), having become reduced, as well as cases requiring hospitalization. A saving for the CHSSS was consistently obtained in sensitivity analysis. Conclusion Providing vitamin supplements for children aged less than 5 years-old would seem to be the least costly and most effective (dominant) strategy for the CHSSS, i.e. compared to not doing so).

Analysis of the direct and indirect costs of treatment of imported malaria in the Slovak Republic / Análise dos custos diretos e indiretos do tratamento da malária importada na República Eslovaca

This study analyzed the approximate cost of treatment of patients hospitalized with a diagnosis of imported malaria in Slovakia. Between 2003 and 2007, 15 patients with imported malaria were hospitalized. The mean direct cost of the treatment was 970.75 euros and the mean indirect cost was 53.15 euros. For the patient with the highest cost of treatment, the use of mefloquine prophylaxis would have represented only 0.5 percent of the total direct cost of treating the disease. Despite the partial resistance of plasmodia, malaria chemoprophylaxis is unequivocally a cheaper choice than subsequent treatment of malaria.

Análise do custo aproximado do tratamento dos doentes hospitalizados na Eslováquia com malária importada. Entre 2003 a 2007, foram internados 15 doentes com malária importada. Os custos médios diretos do tratamento foram avaliados em 920,75 euros e indireto em 53,15 euros. No doente com o custo mais elevado de tratamento, a utilização da profilaxia com mefloquina representaria somente 0,5 por cento do total dos custos diretos do tratamento da doença. Apesar da resistência parcial do plasmódio, a quimioprofilaxia da malária é inequivocamente uma opção mais econômica do que o tratamento posterior da malária.

Relación costo-efectividad del uso de pruebas rápidas para el diagnóstico de la malaria en la Amazonia peruana / Cost-effectiveness ratio of using rapid tests for malaria diagnosis in the Peruvian Amazon

OBJETIVO: Estimar la relación costo-efectividad de tres estrategias de diagnóstico de la malaria basadas en promotores locales de salud en 50 comunidades periféricas de la Amazonia peruana. MÉTODOS: Se evaluó la relación costo-efectividad de tres estrategias de diagnóstico de malaria en pacientes con fiebre de 50 comunidades periféricas de Iquitos, en la Amazonia peruana, que tienen acceso limitado al diagnóstico microscópico y cuentan con una red de promotores locales de salud: sin uso de pruebas rápidas, con uso de pruebas rápidas y con disponibilidad del diagnóstico microscópico. Se compararon y se estimaron los costos y efectos incrementales de las dos últimas estrategias con respecto a la primera (utilizada en la actualidad). La división de los costos incrementales entre los efectos incrementales permitió estimar la razón costo-efectividad incremental. RESULTADOS: El uso de pruebas rápidas ahorraría al Ministerio de Salud del Perú (MSP) US$ 190,81 por caso adicional de malaria por Plasmodium falciparum tratado oportuna y apropiadamente, US$ 31,44 por caso adicional de malaria por P. vivax tratado oportuna y apropiadamente, US$ 1 050,61 por caso de malaria grave evitado y US$ 17 655,20 por cada muerte evitada. Disponer del diagnóstico por microscopía en todas las comunidades generaría al MSP un gasto suplementario de US$ 197,63 por caso adicional de malaria por P. falciparum tratado oportuna y apropiadamente, US$ 31,44 por caso adicional de malaria por P. vivax tratado oportuna y apropiadamente, US$ 1 085,80 por caso de malaria grave evitado y US$ 18 255,46 por cada muerte evitada. CONCLUSIONES: La aplicación de pruebas rápidas de diagnóstico por los promotores locales de salud puede mejorar la efectividad del diagnóstico de la malaria en pacientes con fiebre en las 50 comunidades estudiadas con un costo menor que la estrategia utilizada actualmente. Se recomienda extender el uso de pruebas rápidas por los promotores de salud a otras ...

OBJECTIVE: To determine the cost-effectiveness ratios of three options for diagnosing malaria at the local health provider in 50 communities near the Peruvian Amazon. METHODS: Calculation of the incremental cost-effectiveness ratios of three options for diagnosing malaria-not using rapid tests, using rapid tests, and accessing microscopy-in patients presenting with fever in 50 communities near Iquitos in the Peruvian Amazon, communities with limited access to microscopy that depend on a network of local health providers. The incremental costs and effects of the two latter options were calculated and compared with the first option (currently in use). By dividing the incremental costs among the incremental effects, the incremental costeffectiveness ratio was calculated. RESULTS: Using rapid tests would save the Ministry of Health of Peru: US$ 191 for each new case of Plasmodium falciparum malaria treated promptly and appropriately; US$ 31 per new case of P. vivax malaria treated promptly and appropriately;US$ 1 051 per case of acute malaria averted; and US$ 17 655 for each death avoided. Access to microscopy by all the communities would generate an additional cost of: US$ 198 per new case of P. falciparum malaria treated promptly and appropriately; US$ 31 per new case of P. vivax malaria treated promptly and appropriately; US$ 1 086 per case of acute malaria averted; and US$ 18 255 for each death avoided. CONCLUSIONS: The use of rapid tests by local health providers can improve the effectiveness of malaria diagnosis in patients with fever in the 50 communities studied, at a cost lower than the current method. The recommendation is to expand the use of rapid tests among the health providers in communities similar to those studied.

DDT reintroduction for malaria control: the cost-benefit debate for public health

DDT is a persistent insecticide that was widely used in the world from the 1940s until the 70s, when it was banned in the United States and other countries. Most of its toxic effects are not observed in the acute forms, but particularly after chronic exposure. These long-term issues include reproductive effects, varying according to the time of life in which the individuals were exposed. The aims of the current study were to review the principal toxicological effects of DDT on reproduction, stratifying by physiological periods of exposure, and based on the magnitude of these effects, to discuss the cost-benefit relationship of reintroducing DDT with the specifically defined vector control criteria.

O DDT é um inseticida persistente que foi amplamente utilizado no mundo a partir da década de 40 até a de 70, quando foi banido nos Estados Unidos e outros países. A maioria dos efeitos de sua toxicidade não é observável em formas agudas, mas especialmente após exposições crônicas. Dentre estes aspectos em longo prazo estão os efeitos reprodutivos, que variam de acordo com o a época da vida em que as pessoas foram expostas. Os objetivos deste estudo são: revisar os principais efeitos toxicológicos do DDT na reprodução, estratificando de acordo com os períodos fisiológicos de exposição; e a partir da magnitude destes efeitos discutir o custo-benefício da volta da utilização do DDT com critérios definidos de eliminação de vetores da malária.

Economic cost of malaria on households during a transmission season in Khartoum State, Sudan

This study was conducted in 2004 among 1200 households in Khartoum to estimate the direct and indirect economic costs of malaria for households. Information on the household and the malaria episodes was collected [care-seeking behaviour, working days lost and expenditure on malaria treatment]. There were 327 episodes of malaria; 25.2% of the households reported at least 1 malaria episode during the month preceding the survey. In only 18.0% of malaria episodes was the individual economically active. The average treatment expenditure per fully cured case was US$ 6.3 [SD 5.9]. The average indirect cost per fully cured case was US$ 3.2 [SD 9.2]; it was higher for individuals working in the informal sector than those employed in the formal sector

Costo efectividad del cambio de los esquemas de tratamiento para malaria en el Perú (1999-2003) / Cost-effectiviness of change in malaria treatment regimens in Peru (1999-2003)

Objetivos: Como respuesta a la emergencia de la resistencia del P. falciparum a los antimaláricos, el Ministerio de Salud del Perú decidió adoptar los esquemas de tratamiento para malaria combinados recomendados por la OMS: MQ-AS y SPAS, pero el costo de la nueva terapia es significativamente superior a los anteriores esquemas; SP y quinina + tetraciclina,sin embargo tendría como ventaja una mayor eficacia y probablemente la capacidad de disminuir la transmisión. Por estos motivos se evaluó de manera prospectiva el costo efectividad del cambio en los esquemas de tratamiento para malaria. Materiales y métodos: Se uso el método de análisis de decisiones y de riesgos, se construyó un modelo probabilístico que estableció las relaciones formales entre diversos factores que van a modificar el número de casos, muertes, los añosde vida ajustados por discapacidad (AVAD) y los costos del programa en un periodo de cinco años. Resultados: Se halló que si bien el costo unitario por tratamiento es mayor con el esquema de tratamiento combinado, el uso del nuevo esquema es más costo efectivo en reducir los AVADs. Conclusiones: En el marco de la estrategia del control de la malaria en el Perú, la terapia combinada es más costo efectiva que los anteriores esquemas.

Objectives: As a response to the emergency of P. falciparum resistence to antimalarial agents, Peruvian Ministry of Health decided to adopt combined treatment regimens for malaria recommended by World Health Organization: MQ, -AS and SP-AS, but the costs of the new therapy are significantly higher compared to former treatment regimens; SP and quinine + tetracyclin; however its advantage may be greater efficacy and probably its capacity for reducing transmission. For these reasons, we prospectively assessed costeffectiveness of changing treatment regimens for malaria. Materials and methods: Decision and risk analysis methods were used, a probabilistic model was build establishing formal relationships between different factors that may modify case number, death toll, disability-adjusted life years (DALYs), and program costs for a 5-year period. Results: Even though unit costs for drugs are higher with combined therapy, new combined therapy schedule has better cost-effectiveness for reducing life years adjusted for discapacity. Conclusions: Within the strategy for malaria control in Peru, combined therapy has better cost-effectiveness compared to former treatment regimens.

Associação entre a produção anual de ouro em garimpos e incidência de malária em Mato Grosso - Brasil, 1985-1996 / Association between reported annual gold mining extraction and incidence of malaria in Mato Grosso-Brazil, 1985-1996

Baseado em dados secundários realizou-se análise epidemiológica do tipo ecológico da série histórica da incidência parasitária anual da malária, produçäo oficial anual garimpeira de ouro e gastos financeiros do Programa de Controle da Malária na Bacia Amazônica relativo ao Estado de Mato Grosso, no período de 1985-1996. Associaçäo positiva e estatisticamente significante (p<0,001) entre produçäo de ouro e IPA foi observada em análise multivariada, ainda que controlada por gastos financeiros. Esse achado contribui para a elucidaçäo da tendência de reduçäo da malária em MT, observada na última década

Poverty and malaria: a study in a Thai-Myanmar border area.

An eight-month qualitative study was conducted in 1999 in four villages of Bong Tee subdistrict, Kanchanaburi Province located along the Thai-Myanmar border area using in-depth interviews of key informants and malaria survey as research methodologies. Malaria was a serious problem in 39.6% of the families surveyed in June 1999. The four villages located in a valley covered with forests and small streams which were ideal for malaria epidemic. The structure of the villages has been changed from stable communities to disrupted ones divided along ethnic and class lines. There were 5 ethnic groups dominated by ethnic Karen. Villagers were poor and thus deprived of anti-malaria resources which allow them to remain exposed to malaria.

Cost and performance of malaria sector: a case study at Malaria Sector 11, Tak Province, Thailand.

The objective of this study was to assess the cost and performance of each operational unit at the malaria sector level and to calculate the unit cost of each activity accordingly. Data were collected at Malaria Sector No.11 situated at the western border of Thailand with Myanmar during the fiscal year of 1995. The unit cost was calculated by dividing the total cost of each activity by its output using appropriate units of analysis. The result showed that 67% of the total cost of malaria sector was labor cost and 45% of the total cost was allocated to diagnosis and treatment activities. Unit cost in terms of cost/visit, cost/case found, cost/case of falciparum malaria treated, cost/case of vivax malaria treated, cost/house spray and cost/impregnated net were US$1.85, 8.21, 10.07, 8.46, 2.24 and 1.54 respectively. The results of this study will provide important information as to the best use of limited available resources to determine which activities should be stopped, continued, increased or decreased at the malaria sector level.

Impacto económico de la malaria en el Perú / Economic impact of malaria in Peru

Contiene: La malaria en el Perú y en el mundo; Estrategias de prevención y control; El cálculo de los costos en el marco de la reforma de salud; Una visión global del sector en el proceso de reforma; La teoría económica, los costos y la economía de la salud; El estudio de los costos económicos de la malaria y sus implicaciones; Aspectos considerados en el cálculo de los costos; Costos económicos y efectos sobre el estado de salud; Concepción de los costos económicos; Metodología utilizada en el cálculo de los costos de la malaria; Técnicas e instrumentos metodológicos considerados; Posibles sesgos y deficiencias de la metodología utilizada; El costo económico de la malaria; Los costos de la malaria para las familias

Application of geographical information systems to co-analysis of disease and economic resources: dengue and malaria in Thailand.

Two vector-borne communicable diseases, malaria and dengue, are among a number of diseases of particular importance in relation to economic development in Southeast Asia and thus need to be assessed in relation to economic parameters in the region. Geographical Information Systems (GIS) provide one means of comparing disease and resource data versus time and place, to facilitate rapid visualization by planners and administrators. Given that Thailand is a global epicenter of multidrug resistant falciparum malaria and of dengue hemorrhagic fever, both of which are mosquito-borne, application of GIS methods to these two diseases gives opportunity for comparison of resource needs and allocation in relation to disease epidemiologic patterns. This study examined per capita gross provincial product (GPPpc) and health care resources in relation to geographic distribution of malaria and dengue in Thailand. The two diseases vary greatly in overall seasonal patterns and in relation to provincial economic status, and present differing demands on resource utilization: planned integration of control of malaria and dengue could utilize such analyses in relation to resource sharing and consideration of allocative efficiency. The concentration of malaria (and to a lesser extent dengue) along international border areas underscores the desirability of multi-country coordination of disease management and control programs. Because socio-economic and disease data are collected by quite different means and in different time frames, there are some limitations to the dynamic interpolation of these two broad data sets, but useful inferences can be drawn from this approach for application to overall planning, at both national and multi-country levels.

Anopheline species complexes & malaria control.

Species complexes comprising morphologically indistinguishable biological species that are reproductively isolated, are of common occurrence among anophelines. A list of anopheline species complexes identified so far in the world has been given. To demonstrate the importance of species complexes in malaria control, we report the Anopheles culicifacies complex as a case study. An. culicifacies is a major vector of malaria in India and neighbouring countries. This complex comprises four sibling species, A, B, C and D. Stratification of U.P. state and district Allahabad has been shown taking into consideration the biological differences among sibling species, viz., sibling species composition and vectorial potential- species B is a non-vector while others are vectors. To achieve cost effective vector control, microlevel stratification at least at the block level has been suggested. Implications of differential responses of sibling species to DDT and malathion in field operations have been discussed. To achieve selective and sustainable control, and to reduce the unnecessary selection pressure of insecticides, an insecticide spray strategy to control An. culicifacies has been provided.